Volume I · Chapter 8

Intonation

In the PianoWell approach, intonation is the internal act of singing between notes with glissando and a sense of resistance—similar to legato in instrumental playing or portamento in the voice. Though pianists play fixed keys, the inner awareness of the distance between notes remains just as essential for developing a free, expressive, and singing technique.

Download PDF
Volume
I · Foundation: Mind & Body
Chapter
8
Sections
Theory · Exercises · Practice
Practice Commitment

Theory · Inner Singing

The Role of Intonation

In the PianoWell approach, intonation refers to the internal act of singing between notes with glissando and a sense of resistance—similar to legato in instrumental playing or portamento in vocal technique.

Traditionally, intonation describes the precision of pitch in instruments like strings or in the voice, where the performer must actively sense and shape the distance between pitches. Although pianists press fixed keys, this same inner awareness is just as essential.

Without it, a pianist may struggle with technical stiffness, lack of expressiveness, and disconnection from the musical line. With it, however, you gain access to natural arm weight, nuanced articulation, tonal color, phrasing, and expressive energy when performing on stage.

Resistance: The Hidden Key to Intonation

Adding a sense of resistance to glissando-style internal singing is essential for developing control over the finger muscles of the palm—both in slow and fast tempos.

The energy you feel in this resistance directly translates to the energy and responsiveness in your finger muscles.

This resistance is also key to shaping musical expression. When you sing intervals with gentle resistance, it creates a subtle vibrato and frequency of energy, allowing your musical intention to be fully embodied.

Through this, you gain the ability to express:

  • Arm weight
  • Articulations
  • Harmony
  • Dynamics and voicing
  • Musical speech and phrasing
  • Musical form
  • Your authentic voice
  • Creativity and a sense of confidence

How Intonation Guides Technique

Intonation directly shapes touch, touch influences time and energy, and together, time and energy determine the quality of tone. You can clearly hear this when you sing with different articulations, musical characters, or structural elements—each one alters the timing and energy of your sound.

The same is true when you play. The sensations of intonation—especially the resistance you feel while singing between notes—send impulses to the finger muscles of the palm, which then guide your physical touch at the keyboard.

Because of this, intonation helps your hands remain relaxed and free of excess tension. The expressive energy of dynamics, articulations, and phrasing flows into the hands through the small, responsive muscles of the palm, rather than through force or rigidity in the larger muscles of the hands or arms.

This leads to a fluent, efficient technique, where fingers no longer need to lift excessively or work in isolation. Instead, movement becomes compact, natural, and expressive—centered in the core of the hand and fully guided by inner singing.

The Evolution of Intonation

It’s important to recognize that while resistance in the vocal cords is an essential starting point for developing intonation, this sensation will naturally begin to fade as your practice deepens and more musical elements are integrated.

This fading is not a loss of skill.

In fact, the sense of intonation remains fully present, just in a more refined and subtle form.

If you try to sing without inner singing or any sense of resistance, you’ll quickly notice the difference—revealing how much is still active beneath the surface. What was once a physical feeling becomes more like an energetic awareness or an internal current. This is a natural and necessary shift.

You can compare it to the development of wrist motion at the keyboard:

In the beginning, 2D motion is distinct and deliberate—just as early vocal resistance is clearly felt.

But as you integrate more advanced layers further along, this motion becomes 3D, more fluid and expressive. The original 2D gesture doesn’t disappear—it becomes subtle, embodied, and intuitive, stored in muscle memory. What was once obvious now serves as an invisible foundation for greater freedom and complexity.

In the same way, as you begin using inner singing to express richer dimensions—such as sound texture, harmony, dynamics, or phrasing—the initial sensation of vocal resistance begins to dissolve, making space for a more subtle, internalized sense of intonation. This evolution is a sign of growth, and a sign that your inner voice is becoming more fully aligned with your instrument.

How to Avoid Flat Vibrato in Intonation

At times, students find themselves stuck trying to force vibrato through vocal resistance alone, which often results in a flat, pressured sensation while singing. The sound may feel compressed—lacking amplitude and openness—producing vibrations that remain narrow and low. This can feel similar to working with 2D wrist motion, where something essential—depth, freedom, dimension—is missing.

One common cause is placing too much emphasis on achieving a perfectly smooth glissando. While glissando is an important foundation, over-focusing on it can limit the energy of the sound and prevent natural vibrato from emerging.

Once the sensation of glissando is well internalized, it’s time to shift your focus. Direct your attention to keeping the voice relaxed and free, while allowing the movement of the hands to gently guide the flow of energy. Let the voice stay soft and open—free from any tension.

Exercises

Singing Exercises

When practicing intonation through singing, focus on maintaining relaxation in the hand that mirrors your voice. This hand should move with the same ease and freedom you feel in your singing.

Let the opposite hand provide gentle resistance, offering a subtle counterforce during the motion.

This balance—one hand relaxed, the other gently resisting—helps cultivate a natural vibrato in your vocal intonation.

Over time, as you begin to move your singing hand without the support of the opposing hand, notice how it still glides smoothly, as if through denser air or water. The hand remains soft, but gains momentum from the internal energy you’ve built through this practice.

Guiding Your Focus in Practice

Where you place your attention matters. Focusing too much on trying to produce vibrato through controlled glissando or resistance can actually block its natural flow.

Instead, shift your attention to the sensation of physical movement:

One hand moving freely and gently, like your singing voice. The other hand pressing lightly in the opposite direction, providing just enough resistance to build internal energy.

As you reach the second note of the interval and release the resisting hand, your singing hand will naturally accelerate with momentum. If this inertia is missing, it usually means there wasn’t enough initial resistance.

Guidelines for Singing the Exercises

  • Choose a key that feels comfortable for your voice, and practice all intonation exercises within that key.
  • Sing with sound movement, glissando, and resistance between the notes.
  • Keep your voice free and relaxed, even while introducing resistance.
  • Use your hands to reflect the sound movement—one hand moves gently through space, while the other creates resistance only during the glissando between notes.
  • There should be no resistance within the notes themselves—only as you begin the transition between them.
  • Avoid lingering too much on the notes, since this may restrict the sense of singing the actual distance between them with enough glissando and resistance.

Exercise 1’

Ascending Intervals

Your left hand (representing your voice) moves to the right.

Your right hand provides resistance against the left, only during the glissando between notes.

Exercise 1’

Descending Intervals

Your right hand (your voice) moves to the left.

Your left hand creates resistance against the right during the glissando.

To better feel the distance when singing a small interval like a second or third, picture the notes positioned at the extreme ends of the keyboard. This mental image creates a clearer sense of space, supporting secure intonation with glissando and resistance.

In descending intervals, glissando and resistance are often harder to maintain. Glissando can feel awkward, like trying to read from right to left — less natural for our eyes. Resistance is equally challenging, since moving downward in singing can resemble the pull of falling downhill. Be mindful of this when you sing, and dedicate a bit more practice to descending intervals. Gradually, the feeling of glissando and resistance will become as reliable as in ascending motion.

Sing the interval out loud first, and then repeat it internally.

Exercise no.1 Similar motion

Ascending

Descending

c - d
c - b
c - e
c - a
c - f
c - g
c - f#
c - f#
c - g
c - f
c - a
c - e
c - b
c - d
c - c
c - c

Exercise no.2 Contrary motion

Ascending

Descending

c - d - c
c - b - c
c - e - c
c - a - c
c - f - c
c - g - c
c - f# - c
c - f# - c
c - g - c
c - f - c
c - a - c
c - e - c
c - b - c
c - d - c
c - c - c
c - c - c

Exercise no.3 Contrary motion

Ascending

Descending

c - d - c - e
c - b - c - a
c - f - c - f#
c - g - c - f#
c - g - c - a
c - f - c - e
c - b - c - c
c - d - c - c

Playing Exercises

Hands Separate

Play

Play the interval with 3D wrist motion.

Intonate

Sing the interval internally with intonation.

You might feel less vibration in your vocal cords than when singing out loud, but this is fine.

Play & Intonate

Play the interval while singing internally — intonating the space between the notes.

Let your finger arrive at the next note at the same moment your inner voice reaches it.

Keep your hands relaxed, loose, light, empty, and weak while playing.

The sensation of resistance in your vocal cords can provoke excessive tension in the hands. Just like in singing, it’s crucial to focus on the right objective. Instead of fixating on the tension in your palm muscles as they reflect resistance in intonation (a result of the process), focus on inner singing while keeping your hand loose and relaxed.

The sensation of impulses in your palm will develop naturally over time—don’t force it, as this will only create unnecessary tension.

Avoid humming while playing, so that the resistance in your vocal cords can be directed toward the finger muscles rather than into the voice.

It’s easier to start exercises no.1 and 2 with the 2nd finger rather than the thumb.

Hands Together

Play

Play the interval with 3D wrist motion.

Play & Intonate

Add intonation to your playing.

Keep your hands relaxed while playing.

When intonating and playing with both hands, it’s completely natural to feel only about 50% of the resistance and glissando in your intonation. What should remain is simply a sensation similar to swimming in the ocean. No need to overthink it.

Exercise no.1 Similar motion

Ascending

Descending

c - d
c - b
c - e
c - a
c - f
c - g
c - f#
c - f#
c - g
c - f

Exercise no.2 Contrary motion

Ascending

Descending

c - d - c
c - b - c
c - e - c
c - a - c
c - f - c
c - g - c
c - f# - c
c - f# - c
c - g - c
c - f - c

Exercise no.3 Contrary motion

Ascending

Descending

c - d - c - e
c - b - c - a
c - f - c - f#
c - g - c - f#
c - g - c - a
c - f - c - e

The playing exercises are limited to one position, in order to reduce complexity and prevent unnecessary strain from thinking about elbow motion when reaching a seventh or octave. This keeps the focus clear and simple. If you already feel confident, you may extend the work beyond one position and follow the patterns used in the singing exercises.

Practice

Score

C. Schafer

Sight Reading Exercises

Book 1, Op. 45

Open Score

View the score

Practice

Work through five pages in the book

Hands Separate

Practice in 4-bar sections

Play slowly at 50-60 bpm a note. Give each note the same duration, without applying rhythm, dynamics or articulations. Remind yourself that when you play with gentle, relaxed hands, the natural tone will also stay soft and free of tension—resulting in a naturally quiet dynamic (piano). While the goal is not specifically to play at a piano dynamic, pay close attention to the tone and ensure it remains soft and relaxed throughout your practice.

Elbow Motion

Markings

– Using the sustain pedal while practicing with intonation—especially in the early stages—can interfere with sensing the distance between notes through glissando and resistance.

For now, avoid using the pedal.

Mark fingering and position-change notes in the score where necessary.

Hand Motion

Playing

50 bpm a note

Play using 3D wrist and elbow motion, gently releasing the fingers on circled notes if they appear in the score.

Intonation

Singing

Sing each bar out loud with intonation: with clear sound movement, glissando, and resistance. Pause to breathe after each bar. Sing without rhythm, avoiding staying on any note too long.

Sing all 4 bars internally with intonation.

– No hand movement is necessary—focus entirely on the inner sensation of intonation.

Intonation

Playing

30 bpm a note

Play with 3D motion and intonation.

– Keep your hands relaxed, loose, light, empty, and weak throughout your playing. Let the hands remain soft and weightless, simply channeling the energy of intonation.

– Remind yourself that at this slow tempo, the amplitude of 'rolls and swings' will be naturally more pronounced.

Intonation

Energy

30 bpm a note

Play with 3D motion and intonation, infusing intonation with the energy of your needs / dreams.

Hands Together

Practice in 4-bar sections

Play at a slow tempo, this time incorporating rhythm. Play without dynamics or articulations.

Hand Motion

Playing

Play using 3D wrist and elbow motion, gently releasing the fingers on circled notes if they appear in the score.

– If wrist tension arises when holding long notes in one hand, gently add "ghost rolls" on the sustained notes. This prevents static energy and keeps the motion fluid.

Intonation

Playing

Play at a very slow tempo

Play with 3D motion and intonation.

– Remind yourself that when combining both hands with inner singing, it's completely natural to feel only about half of the usual resistance and glissando in your intonation.

– While playing, keep your hands relaxed, loose, and light.

– At this slower tempo, the amplitude of 'rolls and swings' will feel more pronounced—allow that fullness of motion to support your free expression.

Intonation

Energy

Play at a very slow tempo

Play with 3D motion and intonation, infusing intonation with the energy of your dreams.

Open Lessons

Watch Emma teach this chapter

23 filmed open lessons from Emma’s studio, drawn from the original PianoWell program. Play any lesson below — it continues to the next automatically.

Recovery for Pianists (2021) - 4 - Intonation

0 of 23 watched

Open Lesson

Recovery for Pianists (2021) - 4 - Intonation

Playlist

Intonation