Volume II · Chapter 2

Dynamics

Producing a powerful forte without harshness—and the softest, most transparent piano without tension or accidental "ghost" notes—is one of the central challenges of piano technique. A healthy tone at every dynamic level begins with a calm, spacious acoustic in your imagination.

Download PDF
Volume
II · Advanced Mental Practice: Sound Imagination & Intonation
Chapter
2
Sections
Theory · Exercises · Practice
Practice Commitment

Theory · Power & Softness

Forte and Piano: Power and Softness Without Tension

Producing a powerful forte without harshness—and creating the softest, most transparent piano without unwanted tension or accidental "ghost" notes—is one of the central challenges in piano technique.

The following guidance provides a clear foundation.

Key Points for Listening and Imagining Dynamic Levels

Spend a moment listening to the Adagietto from Mahler’s Fifth Symphony at different volume levels. Notice how the character of the sound changes: the transparency and delicacy of piano, and the density, fullness, and saturation of forte.

When imagining these dynamics, maintain a consistent sense of space and resonance. If you mentally "shrink" the sound for piano or imagine forte as flat or aggressive, this often leads to stiffness or unnecessary tension in the hands. A healthy tone begins with a calm, spacious acoustic in your imagination, regardless of dynamic level.

Playing piano Dynamics Without Tension

All dynamics rely on arm-weight transfer, and this is especially true for controlled piano.

A common difficulty among students is an increase in upper-body tension when attempting to play softly. This tension limits control, diminishes tonal colour, and still prevents a truly quiet sound.

Before playing piano always transfer arm weight into the keyboard.

Your control will come from:

  • a clear inner image of the intended sound,
  • sensitivity in the fingertips, and
  • a free, continuous intonation of each interval supported by arm weight.

This combination enables a soft tone that is both expressive and stable, without physical strain.

Marking Dynamics in the Score

As with harmony, our aim is to keep mental practice simple and uncluttered. The clearer the score appears to your mind, the more easily you can focus on imagining the sound. When working with dynamics, this means clarifying what is already present rather than adding new indications. Only introduce markings where the original intent is unclear—for example, in sections with broad crescendos or diminuendos.

Avoid increasing your imagined dynamic every time you encounter a hairpin. In many cases, hairpins simply reflect the natural shift in colour that comes from a change in harmony—becoming slightly brighter, more resonant, or more tense—or they indicate a gentle expressive shaping of the phrasing, where more prominent parts sound slightly more expressive and brighter.

These subtle rises and falls in intensity will emerge naturally through phrasing and intonation. These nuances do not alter the overall dynamic level in your sound imagination.

Keep your notation clean and straightforward. The goal is clarity, not complexity.

  • Highlight the existing written dynamics to keep them visually and mentally prominent.
  • Cross out vague instructions such as dim. or cresc., and replace them with the specific dynamics you intend for each bar or section.
  • Remove hairpins except for those that begin and end with explicit written dynamics. Treat these as true dynamic transitions and write the exact dynamic markings, just as you would in other crescendo or diminuendo passages.

Maintaining a simple, clearly annotated score helps ensure that your sound imagination remains focused and free of unnecessary confusion.

Left: the original score. Right: the same passage annotated — written dynamics highlighted and circled, vague instructions replaced with specific levels, and only true dynamic transitions kept.

Imagination of Forte

Why Forte Begins in the Imagination

A clear imagination of loud sound is essential for producing a healthy forte at the instrument.

If the imagined dynamic is not truly strong, the physical motions described later—such as lifting the fingers or preparing the hand—will not feel natural. Instead, you may introduce unnecessary tension in the wrist and hand.

To check whether your imagined sound is loud enough, try the following:

Imagine an interval with a fully saturated texture—ff—while transferring arm weight, and begin singing the imagined sound.

If your singing does not feel as full or powerful as the example in the video, then your internal forte may in fact be closer to mezzo-piano. In that case, take time to gradually expand your dynamic imagination and allow the sound to grow.

Remind yourself that losing the sense of horizontal sound movement in your imagination often leads to a vertical, harsh, or percussive touch.

Developing a strong link between your inner sound and your physical touch requires patience. With consistent practice, the hands will slowly adapt to what you imagine, responding with greater ease and clarity.

Playing Forte

How to Play Forte at a Slow Tempo

When playing fortissimo at a very slow tempo (around two seconds per note), using double rolls and double swings is often necessary.

When playing slightly faster, the second roll in a double roll often becomes slightly narrower and more elliptical.

Eventually, with sufficient repetition, you will be able to play using only a single roll, supported by the muscle memory developed in the earlier stages, and the motion will remain free of tension.

It is also important to open the hand—lifting the fingers—before playing the next note.

This prevents the accumulation of tension and allows the motion to reflect the full dynamic of your imagined f. It also serves as a valuable strengthening exercise for the finger and palm muscles.

Lifting the fingers should feel like a quick, healthy stretch that begins in the palm, not as something isolated from the rest of the hand. The pattern is simple: begin with a relaxed, closed hand, open it rapidly into a stretch, and return to a relaxed position.

Slow-Tempo Forte: Double Rolls & Swings

Double rolls

  • Release tension with the first, smaller roll.
  • As you reach the top of the second, larger roll, open the hand.
  • Play the next note at the bottom of this second roll.

Double swings

  • Open the hand at the top of the first swing.
  • Play the note at the bottom of the second swing.

In both double rolls and double swings, it is useful to count: "1" and "2" as you play the note, and "&" as you open the hand with the help of the wrist motion.

The opening of the hand should be quick, not gradual—this keeps the motion free, powerful, and aligned with the imagined ff.

How to Open the Hand Without Unhealthy Tension

When lifting the fingers, raise them straight upward rather than curving them. Curving immediately increases wrist tension.

Begin lifting the fingers only as you approach 6 o’clock of the first "roll or swing", reaching full opening at 12 o’clock of the second "roll or swing".

If the fingers are lifted too early or too late—the hand will tense and the motion will lose its natural freedom.

Remember that lifting your fingers is only required in slow tempos.

After each note, allow the hand to release completely. It should feel empty, light, and unengaged. This prevents unnecessary pressure from accumulating in the palm or wrist, which may otherwise lead to discomfort or pain on the underside of the wrist. A fully relaxed hand will also open more naturally and with greater amplitude. If the hand is not sufficiently relaxed, lifting the fingers will feel strained, and weak.

Adequate amplitude in the arm motion is essential when transferring weight before playing. Lift the elbows higher as you lean slightly backward, and allow them to descend as you return forward. This ensures that the imagined power of the sound—together with the arm weight—is transmitted freely to the keyboard.

If the arm motion is too small, the result will be a harsh tone and potential discomfort in the underside of the wrist.

In forte exercises, play the note on the downbeat (1), then lift the finger—opening the hand—on the upbeat (&).

Let the elbow move freely with every note, and lean the torso forward by approximately 30°. This slight forward inclination allows gravity to assist the arm weight, helping to avoid a harsh tone or aggressive key attack.

Breaking Tension Patterns: Rethinking Forte

Keep the following in mind:

  • The stronger your sound imagination, the larger your wrist movement should be. The physical motion reflects the scale and resonance of the imagined sound.
  • Fortissimo often reflects emotional residues of old tension patterns.

Many pianists were told to "play louder, but not harshly," an instruction that easily creates confusion and tension. Over time, this can lead to a subconscious habit of holding excess stiffness when playing forte, causing the wrist motion to become restricted or rigid.

This reaction is understandable and takes time to retrain. Be patient as you build new internal sensations and associations for forte. For now, gently remind yourself that your hands remain light, empty, weak, and free—even in the strongest dynamic.

Paradoxically, a real, resonant forte does not come from muscular effort. It arises from sound imagination, intonation, and the natural transfer of arm weight.

If you still feel limited or not entirely free, Volume III will explore how posture and the correct energetic state support healthy forte playing. Once these elements are integrated, the experience of playing forte becomes both powerful and effortless — permanently.

Exercises

Practice Tips for Forte Exercises

Begin the exercises with the second finger rather than the thumb.

This will make the exercises feel more stable, as developing a sense of ease and security when playing intervals from the thumb takes time.

In fortissimo exercises, use the sustain pedal to enrich the sound texture.

The resulting resonance will be felt more clearly in the muscles, helping them remain free and preventing unnecessary tension.

Slow pace (two seconds per note).

Use ‘double roll and double swing’ wrist motion only for ff exercises, and only at a very slow tempo (approximately two seconds per note). It can be helpful to create a sense of momentum and continuity by aligning your playing with a steady pulse.

  • “1” — lean forward as you transfer arm weight
  • “&” — lean backward
  • “2” (or “down”) — play the first note at the 6 o’clock position
  • “&” (or “open”) — open the hand fully and quickly at 12 o’clock of the second roll or swing. The opening of the hand should occur immediately on the “o” of open, without delay.
  • “3” (or “down”) — play the second note at the 6 o’clock position

Another point to observe is the depth of the wrist movement. Allow the wrist to descend fully to the 6 o’clock position in the second roll and swing. This creates sufficient momentum for a free and effortless opening of the hand.

If the motion is not deep enough—reaching only around the 4 o’clock position—the resulting movement may lack the necessary momentum, making the opening less natural and more effortful.

Finally, to create momentum, it is important that when the hand opens and the fingers lift as a result, the fingers remain stretched and extended in a straight line rather than curling inward. Think of it like a bird generating momentum in flight by fully opening its wings. If the wings are shortened or curved, they lose power and momentum. The longer and more open the wings, the easier it is to sustain movement.

To summarize, for powerful yet free hand movement in forte playing, pay attention to three main elements:

  1. 1

    The depth of the wrist motion in the roll and swing that occurs before opening the hand

  2. 2

    The quickness of opening the hand

  3. 3

    The length and extension of the fingers, without collapsing or curving inward

If practiced correctly in a slow tempo, with double rolls and swings, the hand gradually learns to remain in the same relaxed, free, yet powerful state as you move to faster tempos with single rolls and swings—around one note per second.

Practice

Score

C. Czerny

100 progressive studies

Op. 139 | No.50-100

View the score

Day 1

Practice each step through the entire piece at a slow tempo, without articulations.

Marking the Score

Fingering

Position-Change Notes

Markings

Write down the fingering in the score as you play using an intuitive pedal.

Mark position-change notes and add the pedal indications in the score.

Optional

Hand Motion

You may play through the piece using 3D wrist motion and elbow motion, gently releasing the fingers on the circled notes.

Later, once you feel confident with these skills, this step will no longer be necessary.

Instead, on the following day, you'll move straight to playing with correct hand motion — after first imagining every note in its sound texture.

Day 2

Hands Separate

Pre-practice

Mindset Session

Breathwork, meditations, journaling.

Manifestation (clarify your needs - the energy of your 'dreams').

Sound Texture

Imagination

Imagine each note in sound texture, combining it with sound movement & glissando between notes.

Sound Texture

Playing

Play the piece with 3D hand motion and posture, sound imagination, and intonation & weight.

Hands Together

Sound Texture

Imagination

Imagine the notes in both staves in sound texture with sound movement and glissando.

Sound Texture

Playing

Play the piece with 3D hand motion and posture, sound imagination, intonation & weight.

Energy

Imagination

Imagine the notes in both staves in sound texture with sound movement and glissando, infusing each note with the energy of your needs / dreams.

Energy

Playing

Play the piece with 3D hand motion and posture, sound imagination, intonation & weight, infusing each note and intonation with the energy of your needs / dreams.

Day 3

Hands Together

Reconnecting

with the Day 2 Foundations

Play through the piece with your attention on the Day 2 tasks, gently reminding yourself of the layers you embedded into your imagination and muscle memory the previous day. This will help you maintain clarity as you add the new Day 3 layers.

Harmony

Imagination

Imagine the notes in both staves in sound texture & harmony, with sound movement and glissando.

Listen to the harmony and feel its emotional colour.

Then, imagine the notes as they are written in the score in sound texture and harmony with sound movement and glissando while holding the block chord with the sustain pedal. Imagine passing notes in the same harmony.

Next, imagine the notes again after you release the sustain pedal that was holding the block chord.

Imagine the notes in sound texture and harmony with sound movement and glissando.

Harmony

Playing

Play the piece with 3D motion, sound imagination, intonation & weight.

Trust that hand motions, intonation & arm weight, and posture are in your muscle memory. So you can now focus more attentively on the sound imagination of harmony.

Hands Together

Harmony & Dynamics

Markings & Imagination

Mark the dynamics in the score.

1. Highlight the existing written dynamics to keep them visually and mentally prominent.

2. Cross out vague instructions such as dim. or cresc., and replace them with the specific dynamics you intend for each bar or section.

3. Remove hairpins except for those that begin and end with explicit written dynamics. Treat these as true dynamic transitions and write the exact dynamic markings, just as you would in other crescendo or diminuendo passages.

Then imagine the notes in sound texture, harmony, and dynamics, adding sound movement and glissando.

Harmony & Dynamics

Playing

Play the piece with 3D motion, guided by sound imagination, intonation and arm weight.

Trust that the hand motions, intonation, arm weight, and posture are already anchored in your muscle memory. This allows you to focus more fully on the sound imagination of harmony and dynamics.

When playing forte at a slow tempo, increase the amplitude of the 3D wrist motion so that it reflects the energy of the imagined loud sound, helping the hands and tone remain free of harshness.

When playing piano, remember that you still need the full amount of arm weight to maintain control of touch and tone.

Throughout, keep the hands light, empty, weak, and loose, and allow sound imagination—rather than physical force—to guide the movement.

Open Lessons

Watch Emma teach this chapter

4 filmed open lessons from Emma’s studio, drawn from the original PianoWell program. Play any lesson below — it continues to the next automatically.

Recovery for Pianists (2021) - 10 - Dynamics

0 of 4 watched

Open Lesson

Recovery for Pianists (2021) - 10 - Dynamics

Playlist

Dynamics